72220 stories
·
2 followers

How Government Censors Learned to Nail Jell-O to the Wall

1 Share

During the Cold War, the peoples of Western Europe, the United States, and the Anglosphere more generally enjoyed freedoms denied to those living behind the Iron Curtain. The manner and extent to which the Soviet Union controlled ordinary people were widely considered evidence of its depravity outside the bloc. That civil liberties were essential to human flourishing and that freedom of speech was a cornerstone of democracy were both mainstream viewpoints within Western liberal democracies.

My first personal glimpse of a digital Iron Curtain came during my first trip to mainland China in 2003. The “Great Firewall” was already operational, blocking images of the 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre, among other things.

Just three years before this trip, then-President Bill Clinton had famously scoffed at Chinese censors, dismissing their attempts as futile and joking that it was “sorta like trying to nail Jell-O to the wall.” But my subsequent trips to the country over the years revealed just how expansive and effective digital controls had become: private Chinese companies like Tencent were “playing ball” with government controls and were allowed to grow incredibly rich for doing so; Google websites were blocked entirely; VPNs were often blocked; and an entire ecosystem (a parallel internet of sorts) had grown up around normalized mass surveillance and censorship.

The chatter among European and American expats that I encountered in China was always that such censorship was evidence of the Chinese Communist Party’s obvious moral backwardness (relative to our home countries). The Soviet Union had ended over a decade before my first trip there, but for some reason, the Chinese government hadn’t received the memo that the world was opening up — in civil liberties more generally, not just in markets. There seemed to be a consensus across the free world that the legitimacy of any regime was tied to the extent to which it allowed its citizens to live and speak freely, including to speak truth to power.

In the years that followed my 2003 China trip, Americans increasingly began to see their own civil liberties violated as part of the Global War on Terror: the Patriot Act, warrantless bulk collection of communications, and no-fly lists, to name just three. Then came COVID-19. Civil liberties were trampled on at a global scale, thanks to a “tyranny of experts” that set a new precedent for governments to dictate to citizens: with whom they could associate and when and where; which doctors they should listen to; which citizens were “essential” workers; whether it was okay to “do their own research”; what they could say and publish; and whether their dying mothers had the right to be visited by loved ones.

With every crisis — whether real, exaggerated, or imagined — the trend is for governments to respond with greater controls over their citizens rather than with more freedom.

Economist and historian Robert Higgs describes this phenomenon as “the ratchet effect,” where the size and scope of the state grow with each crisis, and a return to the pre-crisis status quo rarely follows.

The Infrastructure of a Digital Gulag

Over the past decade, there has been what appears to be a concerted effort by governments around the world to build infrastructure that would effectively kill the free and open internet as we know it. Section 230, which gave platforms that exist for user-generated content (Wikipedia, Yelp, Tripadvisor, X, YouTube) the legal certainty they needed to allow their users freedom of expression, has been under attack — including from then-candidate Joe Biden, who told The New York Times in 2020 that it “immediately should be revoked.”

In the European Union, the Digital Services Act (DSA) chills the speech of Europeans and Americans alike — wherever they may be in the world. In August 2024, then-European Commissioner for Internal Market Thierry Breton posted a letter addressed to Elon Musk just hours ahead of Musk’s live X interview with former President and then-candidate Donald Trump. Breton warned of the “risk of amplification of potentially harmful content.” Two years prior, when Musk posted “the bird is freed,” Breton replied that “In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules.”

What did the DSA, an EU law, have to do with a conversation between an American entrepreneur and an American presidential candidate on an American platform, protected by Section 230 and the First Amendment?

The simple answer, according to Breton, was that the interview would “also be accessible to users in the EU.” So because Europeans have internet access and can consume content generated by Americans and on American platforms, a European law gets to dictate what is said (or what cannot be said).

With the DSA allowing for fines of up to 6 percent of a platform’s global annual turnover, platforms cannot afford to ignore such threats. And why not just disallow European users on the platform? With a population of roughly 450 million people across the EU (a greater population than that of the US), Europe remains an important market for tech companies.

If you think that asserting the right to censor speech across the entire internet is limited to the EU, consider that the UK’s Ofcom and Australia’s eSafety do likewise. Additionally, there is an ever-growing list of member countries whose regulatory agencies operate as a global censorship network called the Global Online Safety Regulators Network.

But the dismantling of the free and open internet is also alive and well in the United States. In 2022, Louisiana passed a law requiring websites to verify a visitor’s age in order to access adult content. This Louisiana law instigated a series of copycat initiatives across the country, with the Free Speech Coalition listing 25 US states (as of November 2026) with age-verification laws in place. The unsurprising result is that users can still access, for example, US pornographic websites by using a VPN to obtain an out-of-state or out-of-country IP address, and they can visit such websites hosted in jurisdictions beyond the enforceability of any US state.

Red states sell the legislation, warning that children can access porn, while blue states emphasize addictive design and social media harm, but both work toward the same objective. Neither side is persuaded that the issue might better be addressed by parents, schools, religious organizations, or voluntary means through the market, such as solutions offered by internet service providers.

The cat-and-mouse game — where innovators work to bring privacy to where it is lacking and lawmakers close the gaps — means that the state inevitably blocks the exits for those wanting to use privacy to live with some level of dignity that was perfectly reasonable to expect in Western liberal democracies during the Cold War.

One attractive feature of peer-to-peer cryptocurrencies, for example, is that they can, when used effectively, provide users with considerably more privacy than the traditional banking system. The legislative response to this innovation has included new reporting requirements for both users and Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs), ramped-up surveillance, and sometimes outright bans. Yet using private methods of payment was considered perfectly reasonable a few decades ago, when cash was more widely used. Someone might, for example, prefer to pay cash for an abortion or a firearm (even where these activities are legal) rather than leave a record of the transaction with a credit card company.

What has changed is the state’s capacity to surveil its citizens and its assertion that every new increment of surveillance capacity should establish a new normal, so that it can conduct law enforcement or provide national security more effectively.

The Machinery of an Unfree Society

A concerted global effort is underway to build infrastructure that would drastically reduce the freedom to consume content without notifying a government or online platform of one’s real-world identity. Digital IDs, age-verification requirements, VPN logging requirements or outright VPN bans, restrictions on cash (for anti-money laundering efforts), the development and launch of central bank digital currencies (CBDCs), and the war against secure hardware and privacy-friendly open-source operating systems all fundamentally change the nature of the internet and chill speech. They enable an unprecedented level of surveillance by both governments and tech companies (aided by the revolving door between the two) and create the ultimate digital panopticon, just waiting for do-gooder social engineers to mold society into something of their own imagining.

And, by the way, none of this is to say anything about the mass use of Flock cameras for real-space surveillance and the next-level-creepy alteration of audio and video feeds of Internet of Things (IoT) devices in the service of government agencies to change the historical record about what actually happens in real-space.

The central problem with all of these measures — to control our data, our devices, the public narrative, our behavior, and even our minds — is that they sleepwalk our societies further in the direction of a high-tech version of everything that Westerners saw as backward in the Soviet Union during the Cold War and what we still condemn in mainland China today. We are observing in real time the construction of a digital gulag, a panopticon for the surveillance and endless social engineering of peoples no longer free but who still believe themselves to be because ballot-box votes are still allowed every few years.

The present author is keenly aware that it has become a cliché to refer to anything creepy and authoritarian as “Orwellian,” and I do not want to overstate the case. But if Orwell’s image of the future with “a boot stamping on a human face — forever” were to come about, what combination of technology and regulations would be necessary for that?

Is that not what is being built?

Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
1 hour ago
reply
Share this story
Delete

Sorkin to Mamdani: Why Won't You Just Condemn the October 7 Attacks?

1 Share


Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
1 hour ago
reply
Share this story
Delete

Russell Brand, the Last Rock Star

1 Share
The West has adopted an incoherent sexual ethic that is bound to be abused.

Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
1 hour ago
reply
Share this story
Delete

Mamdani’s Opportunistic Universalism

1 Share
The mayor promises public benefits for everyone. The reality is more selective.
Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
1 hour ago
reply
Share this story
Delete

New York Punches Down at Horse-Carriage Drivers

1 Share
With a bullying assist from Saturday Night Live, the city’s legislators are mocking and sacrificing these workers—all to appease radical animal rights activists.

Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
1 hour ago
reply
Share this story
Delete

Yes, New York City Protests Can Turn Violent

1 Share
Mayor Mamdani has moved to disband a unit that polices these events. In recent years, it’s been used for when activists get rough.

Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
1 hour ago
reply
Share this story
Delete
Next Page of Stories