72240 stories
·
2 followers

A crime against science

1 Share

Matt Ridley writes, “The plot to discredit the Covid lab leak theory was a crime against science”

Jay Bhattacharya, head of the National Institutes of Health, has written to Nature Medicine journal demanding a “formal, independent investigation” into why a key scientific paper misled the world about the virus causing Covid, and concealed the contributions made by three senior scientists to commissioning, reviewing and editing the paper.

In a career as a science writer that spans more than four decades, I have never seen an alleged case of scientific malpractice as influential. Like many others I have called for the paper to be retracted. Twice, the editor of the journal, Joao Monteiro, has been sent letters from numerous leading scientists demanding an investigation or retraction of the misleading paper. He has ignored us.

I know the paper entitled “Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2” was misleading because I was among those misled. At the time I sat on the science and technology select committee of the House of Lords and we were conducting an inquiry to try to understand this new virus threatening all our lives. The possibility that it had been accidentally released from a laboratory, if true, would have significant implications for the public-health response: a virus marinaded in human tissues in a laboratory for weeks would be far more infectious than one newly arrived from bats.

Parliamentary colleagues were asking me what I thought. To my shame, I told them a lab leak could be ruled out. I did so based almost entirely on the authority of this one paper. That very phrase “ruled out” appeared in the press announcement of the paper from the institution where the lead author, Kristian Andersen, worked. The article itself left no room for doubt: “we do not believe that any type of laboratory based scenario is plausible… our analyses clearly show that SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct.”

That these words appeared in Nature Medicine gave them a stamp of authority, or so I believed. The paper was subsequently viewed millions of times and cited in thousands of academic papers. The journal and the authors of the paper therefore had a special responsibility not to allow themselves to be misled. Yet we now know that Proximal Origin’s arguments were flawed and released Slack messages and emails show several of its authors were expressing exactly the opposite opinion in private both before, during and after publication. They still thought a lab leak was “friggin likely”, in the words of Andersen.

Worse than all that, congressional investigations have uncovered records strongly indicating that three of the most senior medical scientists in the world, Francis Collins (Bhattacharya’s predecessor as head of the National Institutes of Health), Anthony Fauci (head of National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases) and Jeremy Farrar (head of the Wellcome Trust) had not only seen the paper before publication, but – according to a House Select Subcommittee report – had prompted its authors to write it in the first place, had reviewed it and even suggested alterations in wording. Fauci referred to the paper from the White House podium, giving no hint of his own role in it.

Science requires honest admission of error. Ridley’s done his. Now the authors and undisclosed funders of this paper need to step up, alongside the editor of Nature Medicine, Joao Monteiro. If they do not, we are entitled to conclude that they were deliberately lying.

Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
42 seconds ago
reply
Share this story
Delete

Samizdata quote of the day – The danger of forbidden knowledge

1 Share

If academics and students think that someone holding Cofnas’s views is wrong, then they should be able to refute his claims. But that is not what they tried to do. They tried to prevent him from speaking to a small number of students in their spare time and then tried to stop students from getting into the lecture hall to hear him. This is not evidence of intellectual strength. It is evidence of intellectual failure. And that encourages interest in the forbidden subject.

– Douglas Murray

Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
50 seconds ago
reply
Share this story
Delete

Samizdata quote of the day – A bizarre interlude on the BBC

1 Share

Ms Spurrell had already told Campbell’s listeners the opposite. The anti-racism guidelines, she said, were perfectly good.

It got stranger. Among her ideas for winning public respect was police officers dancing with drag queens.

Ask the pensioner whose shed has been emptied twice since Easter what she wants from her local force. I promise you it isn’t a constable who can twerk.

– Gawain Towler

Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
1 minute ago
reply
Share this story
Delete

$3.84 and the lattice of coincidence

1 Share
(Bill Glahn)

With the “affordability” psyop on temporary pause, gasoline prices continue to plummet, down more than 3 cents/gallon yesterday, according to AAA.

That’s down 20 cents in the past week and down 50 cents in the past month. At $3.84/gal., the current price is only 76 cents above the level from a year ago.

The price for diesel is also down 27 cents in the past month.

The affordability psyop is easy enough to understand: it tested well in focus groups and opinion polls, so it’s been pounded relentlessly by Democrats and their media allies since Trump returned to office (remember egg prices?). It’s self-reinforcing as general panic gets reflected in higher commodity prices.

But once you crank up the chaos farming infrastructure, it’s hard to turn off. Yesterday’s four-hour air traffic snafu caused the entire internet to melt down. Yes, it was extremely inconvenient for thousands of travelers. Yes, it will ripple through the network for the next couple of days. It was not the end of the world. Chalk it up to another Friday the 13th.

Last night on Twitter (X), every few minutes I was seeing another false report of a major system failure. The idea seemed to be to drive the public into a general panic with the notion that a “fire sale” was in progress. Every one was using the occasion to ride their favorite hobby horse. Your correspondent was no exception.

On social media, every day the dire warning of impending apocalypse gets postponed. The world was supposed to have ended on Friday, October 30. Then last week. Now it will happen before markets open on Monday, or perhaps on Tuesday at 11 pm GMT. Like the horizon, the end of days perpetually recedes into the distance.

No, the shipping accident in New Orleans was not caused by the air traffic control failure. Power outages were isolated to areas out west experiencing severe weather.

After a while, my feed began to resemble the “lattice of coincidence” speech from the movie Repo Man (1984). For those who remember 42 years later,

You know the way everybody’s into weirdness right now? Books in all the supermarkets about Bermuda triangles, UFOs, how the Mayans invented television. That kind of thing. A lot of people, well, the way I see it, it’s all a part of a cosmic unconsciousness.

Take South America for example. thousands of people go missing every year, nobody knows where they go.

A lot of people don’t realize what’s really going on. They view life as a bunch of unconnected incidents and things. They don’t realize that there’s this lattice of coincidence that lays on top of everything. Give you an example; show you what I mean: suppose you’re thinking about a plate of shrimp. Suddenly someone’ll say plate, or shrimp, or plate of shrimp out of the blue, no explanation. No point in looking for one, either.

Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
1 minute ago
reply
Share this story
Delete

Are Americans Too Dumb to Sustain a Democracy?

1 Share
(John Hinderaker)

I mean that question very seriously. There is a degree of ignorance and, frankly, stupidity, below which a people cannot govern themselves. If we are not at that point yet, we are approaching it rapidly.

This thought is prompted by Eugene Volokh’s citation of a poll that found 39% of Democrats asserting that the entire restaurant industry should be publicly owned and operated.

I suppose it must be fond memories of high school cafeterias that cause these Democrats to think government-run restaurants are a grand idea. I asked Perplexity to estimate how much it would cost to buy the entire U.S. restaurant industry. It came back with a range, the center of which was $700 billion. As someone once said, a hundred billion here, a hundred billion there, and pretty soon you are talking about real money. But the whole $700 billion would be borrowed, so what’s the difference?

The same poll cited by Volokh found that a plurality of Democrats, 46% to 44%, want grocery stores to be owned and run by the government. I thought Zohran Mamdani was crazy when he talked about government-owned grocery stores in New York City, but it turns out he is just a mainstream Democrat.

Why would anyone want the government to run grocery stores? Have people not seen the endless photos of empty grocery stores in socialist countries? Apparently not. I suppose the idea is that government-owned grocery stores would give food away for “free.” The Democratic Party basically consists of people who want to force other people to pay their bills.

There are multiple factors behind the growing stupidity of the American people, but I blame our failed education system more than anything else. Our schools are almost unbelievably bad. Socialism has been tried over and over again–one could argue that of all ideologies, it is the one that has most often been implemented–and it has been the biggest disaster in the history of the human race. The Black Death would probably place second. And yet, our schools are so awful that many of their graduates, perhaps a majority of recent graduates, smugly tell us we should adopt that failed economic and political system.

It is really hard to see how a democracy can be sustained with such voters constituting a numerous, perhaps the most numerous, bloc.

Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
2 minutes ago
reply
Share this story
Delete

No, GTA VI won’t turn you into a rapist

1 Share

The post No, <em>GTA VI</em> won’t turn you into a rapist appeared first on spiked.

Read the whole story
gangsterofboats
15 minutes ago
reply
Share this story
Delete
Next Page of Stories