Egregiously biased online “credibility” arbiter NewsGuard rates several right-leaning U.S. media outlets as less reliable than several state media outlets from tyrannical foreign powers Qatar, communist China and Russia.
Media in China is almost entirely under the control of the ruling Chinese Communist Party (CCP), making outlets propaganda arms for a genocidal government. Tyrannical Russia and Qatar also fund and run state media outlets. China Global Television Network (CGTN) and Global Times, designated by former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo in 2020 as “foreign missions,” and the South China Morning Post have higher NewsGuard ratings than multiple U.S. outlets. So do Qatar’s Al Jazeera and Russia’s RT. NewsGuard gives harsher ratings to Newsmax, OANN and LifeNews than it does foreign state propaganda.
Last year, MRC Free Speech America found for the third year in a row that NewsGuard rated left-leaning media sites 26 points higher on average than right-leaning media sites. But recent MRC research shows that NewsGuard also continues to rate foreign state propaganda higher than several U.S. media sites. NewsGuard attempted to deny its anti-free speech behavior in a recent letter to the Federal Communications Commission, but MRC research shows otherwise.
For instance, NewsGuard gives a Qatari state media outlet a score of 82.5/100: Al Jazeera English. Al Jazeera is funded by and answerable to the Qatari government, which actively harbors Islamic terrorists. Al Jazeera also gives voice to pro-terrorist propaganda, particularly Hamas. Even NewsGuard had to admit that Al Jazeera had promoted egregiously false information about the ongoing Israel-Hamas war, including by falsely blaming Israel for a Gaza hospital explosion, which was actually caused by a misfired Hamas rocket. The New York Times also perpetuated this same falsehood along with several other outlets, for which MRC Free Speech America lambasted NewsGuard for still doling out perfect scores to them at the time.
NewsGuard also admitted that Al Jazeera “promotes violent Islamism, antisemitism, and anti-Americanism, and that it harshly covers government at odds with Qatar,” but ultimately concluded that this applies more to the Arabic version of Al Jazeera than the English version. The Middle East Media Research Institute accused Al Jazeera of complicity in the Oct. 7 Hamas attacks after it aired “exclusive” clips of the massacre, enthusiastically describing the terrorist onslaught as collapsing the “settler walls” and “arrogant occupation army.”
Another state media outlet that receives a higher rating than some U.S. right-leaning media sites is CGTN, a Chinese Communist Party state media outlet. While NewsGuard does not give CGTN a very high score at 39.5/100 — warning that it “severely violates basic journalistic standards” — the so-called media ratings firm still gives CGTN a higher score than at least three American media sites. Global Times, like CGTN, is a Chinese state media site. NewsGuard gives Global Times a credibility rating of 39.5/100. While NewsGuard does disclose the extreme bias of Global Times, including its justification of the ongoing Uyghur genocide in China, it does not mention the fact that Global Times has repeatedly threatened other nations with war, including Australia, the United States and Taiwan.
South China Morning Post (SCMP) is owned by Alibaba, a company founded by Jack Ma and largely owned and controlled by the CCP, according to The National Pulse and Forbes. NewsGuard gives SCMP a stellar rating of 85/100 credibility rating. NewsGuard does not acknowledge SCMP’s CCP ties, though it does admit that the site has become noticeably more pro-China in recent years.
Contrast the ratings NewsGuard gives Al Jazeera and CCP-run CGTN with the 20/100 credibility rating for American media site Newsmax. NewsGuard rates Newsmax as lacking credibility because it disagrees with the authorities that Newsmax cites and claims that certain evidence-based opinions on the media site are false. One of NewsGuard’s main complaints is that Newsmax published an article based on research made public by the surgeon general of Florida, Dr. Joseph Ladapo. NewsGuard denies that the surgeon general is a credible medical authority and instead picked a medical authority, Dr. Paul Offit, who pushed the left’s narrative on COVID-19 vaccines. NewsGuard apparently considers Offit’s statements sufficient to discredit Newsmax for reporting on Ladapo’s research and justify an abysmal rating. NewsGuard also accuses Newsmax of lacking credibility because it reported that President-elect Donald Trump called for National Guard troops on Jan. 6, 2021, which retired U.S. Army Lt. Gen. Keith Kellogg has testified is true.
Outrageously, NewsGuard gives Russian state media outlet RT the same score as Newsmax: 20/100. Though NewsGuard gives RT a negative rating in almost every category, it still rates the Russian media site higher overall than American site LifeNews.
NewsGuard gives LifeNews a 17.5/100 credibility rating and takes issue with the website’s exposure of the harms of abortion and the benefits of pro-life treatments, further exposing its bias by going so far as to call the America media company “anti-abortion.” NewsGuard justifies abortion pills, which doctors have said killed at least two women this year, claiming that abortion pill reversals, which have reportedly saved over 6,000 babies’ lives, are an “unproven process.”
NewsGuard likewise gave another American site, OANN, a horrible rating: 25/100. One accusation NewsGuard makes is that Covid-19 was engineered in a Wuhan, China, lab, a theory for which multiple scientific experts have argued. NewsGuard took issue with OANN interviewing investment expert and data analyst Edward Dowd, who discussed some of the data relative to COVID-19 vaccines.
As always, NewsGuard rates websites as lacking credibility based on whether or not the website promotes sources and opinions with which NewsGuard agrees. Yet one of the categories in which NewsGuard rates Newsmax so badly is handling the difference between news and opinion and gathering and presenting information responsibly. NewsGuard outlandishly claims on one hand that Newsmax, OANN and LifeNews fail to present information responsibly and publish false content, while at the same time claiming Al Jazeera and SCMP have a positive score in both of these categories. It further rates CGTN and Global Times well as far as supposedly not repeatedly publishing false content. NewsGuard also absurdly uses the same language for LifeNews and OANN as it does for RT and CGTN: “severely violates basic journalistic standards.” But it appears that NewsGuard is the one severely violating basic journalistic standards.
NewsGuard has come under scrutiny from Federal Communications Commissioner Brendan Carr, who cited previous MRC research on NewsGuard’s ratings. In 2023 and again in 2024, congressional Republicans put forward legislation concerning the Department of Defense in the National Defense Authorization Act to prevent contracting with online blacklisters, like NewsGuard.
Conservatives are under attack. Contact ABC News (818) 460-7477, CBS News (212) 975-3247and NBC News (212) 664-6192 and demand they report on NewsGuard’s clear left-wing bias, and contact your representatives and insist that they defund and investigate NewsGuard.